Plain Debt Law

A plain-English desk on consumer debt, collection procedure, and the Uniform Commercial Code

How to Read a Collection Complaint or Summons

This page is education, not legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice from a lawyer about your facts. Most collection lawsuits are filed in state court. The civil-procedure rules of the forum state govern what the summons and complaint must contain, how they must be served, and how and when you must respond. Those rules vary. Federal court rules are used here only as general illustrations. They do not automatically apply in a state case. Read the official rules that apply to your matter.

A collection lawsuit usually arrives as two papers that travel together: a summons and a complaint. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's official guidance is to read the lawsuit carefully and respond by the required deadlines. This page is a field guide to those papers. It is not a form bank and it is not a 50-state chart.

Companion pages on this site cover what can follow if the papers go unanswered and what a collection plaintiff has to prove.

The Summons Carries the Deadline

The summons is the court's notice that a case has been filed and that you must respond. Its most important line is the deadline, or the instruction that tells you how to compute the deadline.

The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure again supply a clearly labeled illustration, not a state-court form. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(a)(1) says a summons must name the court and the parties; be directed to the defendant; state the name and address of the plaintiff's attorney or, if unrepresented, of the plaintiff; state the time within which the defendant must appear and defend; notify the defendant that a failure to appear and defend will result in a default judgment against the defendant for the relief demanded in the complaint; be signed by the clerk; and bear the court's seal.

State summons forms differ. Some state a number of days. Some name a hearing date. Some attach a form answer. Some tell you to file with the clerk and to serve a copy on the plaintiff or the plaintiff's lawyer. Read the paper in your hand, not a description of a federal summons.

Service Means the Papers Were Delivered Under the Court's Rules

The Bureau uses the word "served" for the event that starts the lawsuit from the defendant's point of view. Federal Rule 4(c)(1) illustrates the basic pairing in federal court: a summons must be served with a copy of the complaint. The plaintiff is responsible for having both served within the time the rule allows.

Who may serve the papers, whether they may be left with someone else at your home, whether certified mail is enough, and how the server must prove delivery are questions of the forum's rules. A signed return of service in the court file is the plaintiff's usual proof that service occurred. Whether that proof is accurate is a fact question. If you believe you were not properly served, that is an issue to raise in the case under the court's rules. It is not a reason to ignore a deadline that has already been set.

The Complaint States the Claim and the Demand

The complaint is the plaintiff's written claim. Federal Rule 8(a) illustrates what a federal pleading that states a claim for relief must contain: a short and plain statement of the grounds for the court's jurisdiction, unless the court already has jurisdiction; a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief; and a demand for the relief sought.

State complaints often follow a similar pattern even when they do not use that wording. When you read the complaint, look for at least these items, and write down what the paper actually says:

Who is the plaintiff? Is it the company that extended the credit, a later buyer of the account, or a law firm appearing for one of them?

Who is named as the defendant? Is the name, address, and any account reference yours, a similar name, or someone else's?

What kind of account or transaction is alleged? Credit card, medical bill, auto loan, personal loan, or something else?

What amount is claimed as principal, and what is added for interest, fees, costs, or attorney fees?

What dates appear? The date of the account, a charge-off date, the date of a last payment, or the date the plaintiff says it obtained the account?

What legal theory is stated? Common labels include breach of contract, account stated, open account, or unjust enrichment. The label is the plaintiff's theory, not a finding.

What relief is demanded? A money judgment is the usual request. Some complaints also ask for court costs and attorney fees.

None of those questions is a test you have to pass in the abstract. They are a way to compare the paper with your own records before you respond.

The Caption Tells You the Court and the Case Number

At the top of both papers you will usually find a caption: the name of the court, the names of the parties, and a case number. Some courts also print a civil-action number, a county, a docket type, or a statement that the case is a consumer-credit or contract action.

Copy the court name and the case number exactly. You will need both to file an answer, to call the clerk, or to look up the case on the court's site. If the caption names a court in a county or district where you have never lived and where you did not sign the contract, that fact belongs in your notes. It may matter under the forum's venue rules, and, when the plaintiff is a debt collector, under a federal venue statute discussed below.

Who the Plaintiff Is Matters

The Bureau's debt-collection glossary describes an original creditor, generally speaking, as the company that gave you the loan or credit. That company may try to collect a past-due account itself, hire a debt collector, or sell the account. A later buyer is a different party. A companion page on this site covers how the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act treats the original creditor and a later buyer.

On the complaint, the difference shows up in the caption and in the allegations. A complaint filed by "First National Bank" on its own account is one kind of case. A complaint filed by a buyer that says it purchased the account, or by a law firm as counsel for a buyer, is another. The name on the caption is the party asking the court for a judgment. Read it closely, and read any paragraph that describes a sale, assignment, or transfer of the account.

Where the Case Was Filed

If the plaintiff is a "debt collector" as the Act defines that term, Section 1692i(a) limits where the collector may bring a legal action against a consumer. For an action to enforce an interest in real property securing the consumer's obligation, the action may be brought only in the judicial district or similar legal entity in which the property is located. For other actions, the collector may bring the case only in the judicial district or similar legal entity in which the consumer signed the contract sued upon, or in which the consumer resides at the commencement of the action. Section 1692i(b) adds that nothing in the Act authorizes the bringing of legal actions by debt collectors.

That venue rule applies to a debt collector who brings the action. It does not, by its terms, apply to every original creditor. Whether a particular plaintiff is a debt collector is a fact question this page does not settle. State venue rules can also limit where a case may be filed, including a case brought by a creditor who is not a debt collector.

The Answer Date Is on the Court Paper

Do not borrow a deadline from a validation notice, a demand letter, or a rule you read online. The summons, the complaint, or an attached notice states the time to respond, or tells you how to compute it.

Federal Rule 12(a)(1)(A) illustrates a federal timing rule: a defendant must serve an answer within 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint, or within 60 days after a waiver request was sent if the defendant timely waived service under Rule 4(d). Many state courts use a different number of days. Some count from service, some from filing, and some from a stated hearing date. The only safe source is the paper you were served and the rules of that court.

A validation letter sent after you are served does not extend that time. As Section 1692g(d) states, a formal pleading is not an initial communication for purposes of the validation-notice rule.

What an Answer Does

An answer is the defendant's written response, filed with the court and served on the other side under the court's rules. A letter to the collector, a phone call, or a payment arrangement is not an answer unless the court treats it as one, which most courts do not.

Federal Rule 8(b) illustrates the basic choices in a federal answer. A party must state in short and plain terms its defenses to each claim, and must admit or deny the allegations asserted against it. A party that intends in good faith to deny only part of an allegation must admit the part that is true and deny the rest. A party that lacks knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief about the truth of an allegation must so state, and that statement has the effect of a denial. Rule 8(b)(6) then states the cost of silence in a federal answer: an allegation other than one relating to the amount of damages is admitted if a responsive pleading is required and the allegation is not denied.

Rule 8(c) illustrates affirmative defenses that a federal answering party must state, including payment, release, and the statute of limitations. State answer rules may use different labels, different forms, and different waiver rules. Some courts provide a check-box answer form. Some require a numbered response that tracks the complaint paragraph by paragraph. Follow the rules of the court named in the caption.

What This Page Does Not Decide

This page does not tell you the deadline in your court, whether you were properly served, whether the case was filed in the right place, or how to fill out an answer in a particular county. Those questions turn on the forum's rules and on facts. Compare the official rules with the papers in your file, and get legal help when you need it for a specific case.

Sources

Further Reading

The books below are from this publisher's catalog. Links go to the publisher's own titles on Amazon. This site has not joined the Amazon Associates program and does not earn a referral commission from these links.