Plain Debt Law

A plain-English desk on consumer debt, collection procedure, and the Uniform Commercial Code

Defenses, Claims in Recoupment, and Limitation Periods Under UCC Article 3

This page is education, not legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice from a lawyer about your facts. The Uniform Commercial Code sections quoted here are ss. 3-118, 3-305, 3-306, and 3-407 of the official uniform text. The UCC is enacted state by state, often with local changes. The limitation periods in section 3-118 are the official uniform periods. A state's enactment can be different. This page does not publish a 50-state chart, and it does not tell you which defense or period applies to a particular instrument. Read the official enacted text of the relevant state, and get legal help when you need it for a specific case.

A negotiable instrument can be enforced years after it was signed. The person trying to enforce it may be the original payee, a later holder, or a holder in due course. Article 3 separates three related questions: how long the uniform text gives to commence an action, which defenses and claims in recoupment can be asserted, and what happens if the instrument has been altered. Companion pages on this site cover what a negotiable instrument is, who is a person entitled to enforce, and holder-in-due-course status. This page stays on the sections named above.

The Uniform Limitation Periods in Section 3-118

Section 3-118 states limitation periods for actions to enforce obligations on instruments. Those periods are not automatically the law of every state. Check the enacted text.

Under subsection (a), except as provided in subsection (e), an action to enforce the obligation of a party to pay a note payable at a definite time must be commenced within six years after the due date or dates stated in the note or, if a due date is accelerated, within six years after the accelerated due date.

Under subsection (b), except as provided in subsection (d) or (e), if demand for payment is made to the maker of a note payable on demand, an action to enforce the obligation of a party to pay the note must be commenced within six years after the demand. If no demand for payment is made to the maker, an action to enforce the note is barred if neither principal nor interest on the note has been paid for a continuous period of 10 years.

Under subsection (c), except as provided in subsection (d), an action to enforce the obligation of a party to an unaccepted draft to pay the draft must be commenced within three years after dishonor of the draft or 10 years after the date of the draft, whichever period expires first. A check is a draft, so that three-year-or-ten-year rule is the uniform period for an unaccepted check.

The section also states other periods. An action to enforce the obligation of the acceptor of a certified check, or the issuer of a teller's check, cashier's check, or traveler's check, must be commenced within three years after demand for payment is made to the acceptor or issuer. An action to enforce a certificate of deposit is generally six years after demand, with a special rule if the instrument states a due date. An action to enforce an accepted draft other than a certified check follows six-year rules that depend on whether the acceptor's obligation is payable at a definite time or on demand. Unless governed by other law regarding claims for indemnity or contribution, an action for conversion of an instrument, for money had and received or a like action based on conversion, for breach of warranty, or to enforce an obligation, duty, or right arising under Article 3 and not governed by section 3-118 must be commenced within three years after the cause of action accrues.

The uniform text therefore uses six years for a note payable at a definite time, six years after demand on a demand note, and a 10-year bar if no demand is made and neither principal nor interest has been paid for a continuous period of 10 years. For an unaccepted draft or check, it uses three years after dishonor or 10 years after the date, whichever expires first. A state may enact different periods, or may apply a general civil limitation period instead of or in addition to section 3-118. A companion page on this site covers time-barred debt in general. This page does not decide which period a particular court will apply.

Defenses and Claims in Recoupment

Section 3-305 is the principal defenses section. Except as otherwise provided in the section, the right to enforce the obligation of a party to pay an instrument is subject to three categories.

The first category, in subsection (a)(1), is the set of defenses often called real defenses. They are: infancy of the obligor to the extent it is a defense to a simple contract; duress, lack of legal capacity, or illegality of the transaction which, under other law, nullifies the obligation of the obligor; fraud that induced the obligor to sign the instrument with neither knowledge nor reasonable opportunity to learn of its character or its essential terms, sometimes called fraud in the factum; and discharge of the obligor in insolvency proceedings.

The second category, in subsection (a)(2), is a defense of the obligor stated in another section of Article 3, or a defense of the obligor that would be available if the person entitled to enforce the instrument were enforcing a right to payment under a simple contract. Ordinary contract defenses, such as failure of consideration or breach of the underlying agreement, sit here when they would be available on a simple contract.

The third category, in subsection (a)(3), is a claim in recoupment of the obligor against the original payee of the instrument if the claim arose from the transaction that gave rise to the instrument. The claim of the obligor may be asserted against a transferee of the instrument only to reduce the amount owing on the instrument at the time the action is brought. Recoupment is not a free-standing claim for affirmative recovery against a later transferee under this subsection. It is a reduction of the amount owing on the instrument.

Holder-in-due-course status changes which of those categories remain available. Under subsection (b), the right of a holder in due course to enforce the obligation of a party to pay the instrument is subject to defenses of the obligor stated in subsection (a)(1), but is not subject to defenses of the obligor stated in subsection (a)(2) or claims in recoupment stated in subsection (a)(3) against a person other than the holder. A holder in due course still takes subject to the real defenses in (a)(1). Ordinary simple-contract defenses and recoupment claims against someone other than that holder are cut off.

Subsection (c) limits an obligor's use of another person's defense or claim, with a joinder path, and states that an obligor is not obliged to pay the instrument if the person seeking enforcement does not have rights of a holder in due course and the obligor proves that the instrument is a lost or stolen instrument. Subsection (d) addresses accommodation parties. Subsection (e) addresses a consumer transaction in which other law requires a statement that the rights of a holder or transferee are subject to a claim or defense the issuer could assert against the original payee. Subsection (f) states that section 3-305 is subject to law other than this article that establishes a different rule for consumer transactions. Those last provisions are part of the official text. This page does not unpack them.

Claims to an Instrument

Section 3-306 is shorter and is aimed at claims of ownership, not at contract defenses. A person taking an instrument, other than a person having rights of a holder in due course, is subject to a claim of a property or possessory right in the instrument or its proceeds, including a claim to rescind a negotiation and to recover the instrument or its proceeds. A person having rights of a holder in due course takes free of the claim to the instrument.

A claim to the instrument is a claim that the instrument, or its proceeds, belongs to someone else, or that a negotiation should be rescinded. It is not the same as a defense to payment under section 3-305(a)(2) or a claim in recoupment under section 3-305(a)(3). Holder-in-due-course rights cut off a claim to the instrument under section 3-306, just as they cut off personal defenses under section 3-305(b).

Alteration

Section 3-407 defines "alteration" as an unauthorized change in an instrument that purports to modify in any respect the obligation of a party, or an unauthorized addition of words or numbers or other change to an incomplete instrument relating to the obligation of a party. Except as provided in subsection (c), an alteration fraudulently made discharges a party whose obligation is affected by the alteration unless that party assents or is precluded from asserting the alteration. No other alteration discharges a party, and the instrument may be enforced according to its original terms.

A payor bank or drawee paying a fraudulently altered instrument, or a person taking it for value, in good faith and without notice of the alteration, may enforce rights with respect to the instrument according to its original terms, or, in the case of an incomplete instrument altered by unauthorized completion, according to its terms as completed. The official text therefore distinguishes a fraudulent alteration, which can discharge an affected party, from a non-fraudulent alteration, which does not discharge a party and leaves the instrument enforceable according to its original terms, and then preserves enforcement rights for a good-faith payor or taker for value without notice.

What This Page Does Not Decide

This page does not decide whether a particular person is a holder in due course, whether a particular defense or recoupment claim is available, or which limitation period a court will apply. It does not treat the uniform six-year and three-year periods as the law of every state. It does not unpack section 3-302, which defines holder-in-due-course status, or section 3-309, which addresses lost, destroyed, or stolen instruments. Read the enacted text of the relevant state, compare it with the instrument and the claim actually made, and get legal help when you need it for a specific case.

Sources

Further Reading

The books below are from this publisher's catalog. Links go to the publisher's own titles on Amazon. This site has not joined the Amazon Associates program and does not earn a referral commission from these links.