Plain Debt Law

A plain-English desk on consumer debt, collection procedure, and the Uniform Commercial Code

Accord and Satisfaction by Check Under UCC 3-311: What "Paid in Full" Actually Requires

This page is education, not legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice from a lawyer about your facts. Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code is state law. States enact the uniform text, sometimes with local changes. Section 3-311 is a rule about discharge of a claim by use of an instrument, such as a check. It is not a general law of settlement, and it is not a rule that any check bearing the words "paid in full" wipes out a balance. Read the official text in force in the relevant state.

People often write "paid in full," "full and final," or similar words on a check for less than the amount a creditor says is due, and then treat the cashing of that check as the end of the debt. Section 3-311 sometimes produces a discharge, and sometimes it does not. The difference is in the conditions the section requires the person who tendered the instrument to prove. This page stays on those conditions.

The Three Threshold Facts in Subsection (a)

Section 3-311(a) is the gate. If a person against whom a claim is asserted proves three facts, the following subsections apply. First, that person in good faith tendered an instrument to the claimant as full satisfaction of the claim. Second, the amount of the claim was unliquidated or subject to a bona fide dispute. Third, the claimant obtained payment of the instrument.

All three have to be proved by the person who wants the discharge. Good faith tender of an instrument as full satisfaction is the first. The instrument has to have been tendered as full satisfaction, and the tender has to have been in good faith. The section does not define "good faith" in its own text. Whatever that standard is under the official text of the relevant state, it is part of what must be proved.

The second fact is the one most often missed. The amount of the claim must have been unliquidated or subject to a bona fide dispute. An unliquidated claim is one whose amount has not been settled or fixed. A bona fide dispute is a genuine dispute about the claim, not a label placed on an amount that is not actually in dispute. If the claim is for a fixed, undisputed amount, this second fact is not proved by writing "paid in full" on a check for less than that amount.

The third fact is that the claimant obtained payment of the instrument. A check that was never paid does not satisfy this element. A check that was paid does. The later subsections then decide whether that payment, plus the other required showings, discharges the claim.

Why "Paid in Full" on a Partial Check for an Undisputed Debt Does Not Discharge the Balance

Suppose a creditor states a definite balance, the person who owes that balance does not genuinely dispute the amount or the obligation, and that person sends a check for a smaller sum with "paid in full" on the memo line. Section 3-311(a) never opens the rest of the section unless the amount of the claim was unliquidated or subject to a bona fide dispute. A partial payment on an undisputed, liquidated claim does not meet that requirement as written.

The words on the check do not, standing alone, create the dispute or make the claim unliquidated. The person against whom the claim is asserted has to prove that the amount was unliquidated or that a bona fide dispute already existed. If that proof is missing, the later rules about conspicuous statements, designated addresses, and repayment do not come into play under this section, because those rules apply only if subsection (a) is satisfied.

That is the uniform-text reason a "paid in full" legend on a partial check, used against a fixed and undisputed balance, does not discharge the rest of the claim under Section 3-311. Other law of settlement, accord and satisfaction, or account stated may exist in a particular state outside this section. This page does not catalog that other law. It stays on what Section 3-311 itself requires.

The Conspicuous-Statement Rule

If subsection (a) is proved, Section 3-311(b) supplies the ordinary path to discharge. Unless subsection (c) applies, the claim is discharged if the person against whom the claim is asserted proves that the instrument or an accompanying written communication contained a conspicuous statement to the effect that the instrument was tendered as full satisfaction of the claim.

The statement may appear on the instrument or in an accompanying writing. It must be conspicuous, and it must be to the effect that the instrument was tendered as full satisfaction of the claim. A hidden or inconspicuous notation is not what the subsection describes. The person seeking the discharge has to prove that this statement was there.

Two Ways a Claim Is Not Discharged Under Subsection (c)

Section 3-311(c) is subject to subsection (d). A claim is not discharged under subsection (b) if either of two exceptions applies.

The first exception is for an organization that designated a place to send disputed-debt communications. If the claimant is an organization, and it proves that within a reasonable time before the tender it sent a conspicuous statement to the person against whom the claim is asserted that communications concerning disputed debts, including an instrument tendered as full satisfaction of a debt, are to be sent to a designated person, office, or place, and that the instrument or accompanying communication was not received by that designated person, office, or place, the claim is not discharged under subsection (b). An organization that has told people, conspicuously and in time, where to send a full-satisfaction check can defeat a discharge under subsection (b) by proving that the check did not arrive at that designated place.

The second exception is a 90-day tender-back. The claimant, whether or not an organization, proves that within 90 days after payment of the instrument, the claimant tendered repayment of the amount of the instrument to the person against whom the claim is asserted. If the claimant returns the money within that 90-day period, the claim is not discharged under subsection (b). This paragraph does not apply if the claimant is an organization that sent a statement complying with paragraph (1)(i). An organization that used the designated-address procedure does not also have this 90-day repayment path; an organization that did not send that statement, and any claimant who is not an organization, may use the 90-day tender-back.

The Knowledge Exception in Subsection (d)

Section 3-311(d) can restore a discharge even when subsection (c) would otherwise block one. A claim is discharged if the person against whom the claim is asserted proves that within a reasonable time before collection of the instrument was initiated, the claimant, or an agent of the claimant having direct responsibility with respect to the disputed obligation, knew that the instrument was tendered in full satisfaction of the claim.

The knowledge that matters under this subsection is knowledge, within a reasonable time before collection of the instrument was initiated, by the claimant or by an agent with direct responsibility for the disputed obligation. It is not knowledge in general somewhere in a large organization. If that knowledge is proved, the claim is discharged even though the designated-address or 90-day exception in subsection (c) would otherwise have applied.

Putting the Section Together

The order of proof in the uniform text is deliberate. First, the person seeking a discharge must prove a good-faith tender as full satisfaction, an unliquidated claim or a bona fide dispute, and payment of the instrument. Next, that person must prove a conspicuous full-satisfaction statement on the instrument or in an accompanying writing. The claimant may then avoid a discharge under subsection (b) by proving the designated-address exception or the 90-day tender-back, unless the person seeking the discharge proves the knowledge described in subsection (d).

Missing any required piece leaves the claim undischarged under this section. A memo line is not a shortcut around an undisputed, liquidated balance. A cashed check is not, standing alone, an accord and satisfaction under Section 3-311. The official text of the relevant state is the rule to compare with the check, the accompanying writing, and the dispute, if any, that existed when the check was sent. Keep the check, both sides of it, any letter that went with it, and the date the claimant obtained payment.

What This Page Does Not Decide

This page does not tell you whether a particular claim was unliquidated or in bona fide dispute, whether a particular legend was conspicuous, or whether a particular creditor knew that a check was tendered in full satisfaction. Those questions turn on the official text of the relevant state and on facts. Compare that text with the check and the papers in the file, and get legal help when you need it for a specific case.

Sources

Further Reading

The books below are from this publisher's catalog. Links go to the publisher's own titles on Amazon. This site has not joined the Amazon Associates program and does not earn a referral commission from these links.